I didn't realize that you could pick more than one, so I only picked werewolf after deliberation. Think about it, if it's one of those werewolves that is in control, you could have it bite you so you would also be a werewolf; which is probably a fantasy for at least 1/4 of the people on this site. You get a giant knotted cock, or a puffy canine pussy depending on your sex which would make the sex with it even more enjoyable, because of how sensitive a canine penis is, a sexy wolf ass regardless of your sex, plus regeneration and immortality. It would be amazing to see how it feels to knot someone or to have a pussy made for knotting.
Things I would fuck in the "Other" category... Horse satyr, centaur, dire wolf, were(bear, deer, horse, or big cat).