I have lots of toys in my collection from Exotic Erotics, Bad Dragon, Square Peg (non-animal shapes, so I'll disregard them here), and Yiffmonkey (which I include because I have their werewolf toy in XXL and that's sooort of adjacent).
Exotic Erotics makes great toys. The first toy I ordered from Exotic Erotics was their Charlie (some 10 years ago) and I still use it today (I can take it to the hilt nowadays), but my collection has grown to include Motown, Henry, their Wuffamute, the Werewolf XL, and probably a few others. Their toys tend to have very lightly textured surfaces (i.e. not super, super smooth) which I personally like. The lifecast models are a bit variable in texture - my Charlie is
very textured and feels almost exactly like what a stallion's cock would if it were made from silicon (based on memories from my farm life growing up
), whereas my Henry is a lot smoother and less textured. If you are ordering a toy, I recommend getting a dual-density core for some of the larger horsecocks so that they're a bit firmer around the base.
I own the XL flared Chance from Bad Dragon, and while it's juuust a bit too large for me at the moment the quality is definitely very high. The biggest problem I have with Bad Dragon is that the turnaround on toys is
terrrrrrible. I ordered a toy in January last year and didn't receive it until after April. Any other manufacturer I've ordered from on this list got me my product within 1-2 weeks, and that includes pouring and moulding the toys (i.e. I was not making off-the-rack purchases as far as I am aware). Something to keep in mind when ordering - if you're really fuckin' horny and want something up your tailpipe
now then Bad Dragon is absolutely not the way to go - order a toy from somewhere else to keep your chute slicked while Bad Dragon turns their gears.
I recently found Yiffmonkey on Etsy and ordered their pierced Orc dildo, and it is fantastic for a first toy to open up. I then ordered their Werewolf XXL (because who can have enough knots) and will probably be working on that for the foreseeable future. Both toys are high quality, imo, and many are offered in a huge range of sizes to accommodate different levels of skill.