I dunno man, I thought that was pretty dark. I almost didn't even post it! Lol
Last to post wins
- Thread starter Mickthedick22
- Start date
?Hello darkness my old freind...?
Heh, funny. I was also considering asking @UR20Z pretty much the same thing.
Apparently so. I guess we'll never know if he likes the OG or the newfangled rendition.
Right after I hit the post button, I realized I should ETA that I wasn't sure which one would be more appropriate, but just then I got called away from the keyboard, and it slipped my mind until I just saw this exchange. For this situation, I guess the Disturbed version would be more apropos. Darker than S&G's.
I forget the name of the reviewer that said it, but he described the two with words very much like "S&G's version was a warning, and D's is the rage at seeing the warning being ignored".
I do definitely like Disturbed's take on the song. It's darker, well rounded, more modern sounding, and cleaner sounding overall. But me personally I like G&F version better. Mainly because my father used to play Simon & Garfunkel as a kid and hearing them simply takes me back to a simpler time. It's the version of the song I grew up with and liked. Chicago (the band not the city) essentially does the same thing. Hearing one of Chicago's songs is always a classic hit from the nostalgia pipe.
blackrosehorse
Tourist
salut
Ladyprincess
Lurker
Post
Ladyprincess
Lurker
Cheese
Shaddap, loser! <PHLLLLLBBTTT!>
Ladyprincess
Lurker
I win
You aren't evil enough. You lose! BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
on_niesmialy
Tourist
W I N
beastgirl86
Lurker
Y'know, these declarations are kinda like a teenager getting his first piece of ass - Premature!
